Update CheckPackageLimits to use util::Result to pass the error message
instead of out parameter.
Also update test to reflect the error message from `CTxMempool`
`CheckPackageLimits` output.
91504cbe0d rpc: `SyncWithValidationInterfaceQueue` on fee estimation RPC's (ismaelsadeeq)
714523918b tx fees, policy: CBlockPolicyEstimator update from `CValidationInterface` notifications (ismaelsadeeq)
dff5ad3b99 CValidationInterface: modify the parameter of `TransactionAddedToMempool` (ismaelsadeeq)
91532bd382 tx fees, policy: update `CBlockPolicyEstimator::processBlock` parameter (ismaelsadeeq)
bfcd401368 CValidationInterface, mempool: add new callback to `CValidationInterface` (ismaelsadeeq)
0889e07987 tx fees, policy: cast with static_cast instead of C-Style cast (ismaelsadeeq)
a0e3eb7549 tx fees, policy: bugfix: move `removeTx` into reason != `BLOCK` condition (ismaelsadeeq)
Pull request description:
This is an attempt to #11775
This Pr will enable fee estimator to listen to ValidationInterface notifications to process new transactions added and removed from the mempool.
This PR includes the following changes:
- Added a new callback to the Validation Interface `MempoolTransactionsRemovedForConnectedBlock`, which notifies listeners about the transactions that have been removed due to a new block being connected, along with the height at which the transactions were removed.
- Modified the `TransactionAddedToMempool` callback parameter to include additional information about the transaction needed for fee estimation.
- Updated `CBlockPolicyEstimator` to process transactions using` CTransactionRef` instead of `CTxMempoolEntry.`
- Implemented the `CValidationInterface` interface in `CBlockPolicyEstimater` and overridden the `TransactionAddedToMempool`, `TransactionRemovedFromMempool`, and `MempoolTransactionsRemovedForConnectedBlock` methods to receive updates from their notifications.
Prior to this PR, the fee estimator updates from the mempool, i.e whenever a new block is connected all transactions in the block that are in our mempool are going to be removed using the `removeForBlock` function in `txmempool.cpp`.
This removal triggered updates to the fee estimator. As a result, the fee estimator would block mempool's `cs` until it finished updating every time a new block was connected.
Instead of being blocked only on mempool tx removal, we were blocking on both tx removal and fee estimator updating.
If we want to further improve fee estimation, or add heavy-calulation steps to it, it is currently not viable as we would be slowing down block relay in the process
This PR is smaller in terms of the changes made compared to #11775, as it focuses solely on enabling fee estimator updates from the validationInterface/cscheduler thread notifications.
I have not split the validation interface because, as I understand it, the rationale behind the split in #11775 was to have `MempoolInterface` signals come from the mempool and `CValidationInterface` events come from validation. I believe this separation can be achieved in a separate refactoring PR when the need arises.
Also left out some commits from #11775
- Some refactoring which are no longer needed.
- Handle reorgs much better in fee estimator.
- Track witness hash malleation in fee estimator
I believe they are a separate change that can come in a follow-up after this.
ACKs for top commit:
achow101:
ACK 91504cbe0d
TheCharlatan:
Re-ACK 91504cbe0d
willcl-ark:
ACK 91504cbe0d
Tree-SHA512: 846dfb9da57a8a42458827b8975722d153907fe6302ad65748d74f311e1925557ad951c3d95fe71fb90ddcc8a3710c45abb343ab86b88780871cb9c38c72c7b1
705e3f1de0 refactor: Make CTxMemPoolEntry only explicitly copyable (TheCharlatan)
Pull request description:
This has the goal of prohibiting users from accidentally creating runtime failures, e.g. by interacting with iterator_to with a copied entry. This was brought up here: https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/28886#issuecomment-1814794954.
CTxMemPoolEntry is already implicitly not move-constructable. So be explicit about this and use a std::list to collect the values in the policy_estimator fuzz test instead of a std::vector.
ACKs for top commit:
maflcko:
ACK 705e3f1de0🌯
achow101:
ACK 705e3f1de0
ajtowns:
ACK 705e3f1de0
ismaelsadeeq:
ACK 705e3f1de0
Tree-SHA512: 62056905c679c919d00f9ae065ed66ac986e7e7062015aea542843d8deecda57104d7a68d002f7b20afa3164f8e9215d2d2d002c167224129540e3b1bd0712cc
`CBlockPolicyEstimator` will implement `CValidationInterface` and
subscribe to its notification to process transactions added and removed
from the mempool.
Re-delegate calculation of `validForFeeEstimation` from validation to fee estimator.
Also clean up the validForFeeEstimation arg thats no longer needed in `CTxMempool`.
Co-authored-by: Matt Corallo <git@bluematt.me>
This commit adds a new callback `MempoolTransactionsRemovedForBlock` which notify
its listeners of the transactions that are removed from the mempool because a new
block is connected, along with the block height the transactions were removed.
The transactions are in `RemovedMempoolTransactionInfo` format.
`CTransactionRef`, base fee, virtual size, and height which the transaction was added
to the mempool are all members of the struct called `RemovedMempoolTransactionInfo`.
A struct `NewMempoolTransactionInfo`, which has fields similar to `RemovedMempoolTransactionInfo`,
will be added in a later commit, create a struct `TransactionInfo` with all similar fields.
They can both have a member with type `TransactionInfo`.
If the removal reason of a transaction is BLOCK, then the `removeTx`
boolean argument should be true.
Before this PR, `CBlockPolicyEstimator` have to complete updating the fee stats
before the mempool clears that's why having removeTx call outside reason!= `BLOCK`
in `addUnchecked` was not a bug.
But in a case where the `CBlockPolicyEstimator` update is asynchronous, the mempool might
clear before we update the `CBlockPolicyEstimator` fee stats.
Transactions that are removed for `BLOCK` reasons will also be incorrectly removed from
`CBlockPolicyEstimator` stats as failures.
