For reasons I do not really grok, this PR changes the timing behavior of the
functional tests to reliably expose a deadlock in the claimpegin RPC that has
existed since the 0.17 rebase.
The mechanism is: in `claimpegin` in src/wallet/rpcwallet.cpp:5873, we call
`AcceptToMemoryPoolWorker`. This requires cs_main to be locked, which it is
not (contrast Core's `testmempoolaccept` RPC, which similarly calls
`AcceptToMemoryPoolWorker` from the RPC thread, and locks cs_main immediately
before).
We do *say* that it is locked, in the `LockAssertion` one the line above, but
this was added in ad3d496d78 during the 0.17
rebase (PR #620), apparently to shut up some linter on OSX, and as near as I
can tell it was never true.
Anyway, `AcceptToMemoryPoolWorker` calls through a couple layers which assume
cs_main is locked, to `AcceptSingleTransaction`, which locks m_pool.cs on line
src/validation.cpp:1101. It then calls `PreChecks`, which on line 784 calls
::ChainActive(), which _actually_ locks cs_main, though only briefly. This
line is the deadlock, because we locked m_pool.cs followed by cs_main...
...meanwhile, in src/net_processing.cpp, we lock cs_main at the top of the
`PeerLogicValidation::SendMessages` loop (src/net_processing.cpp:3628). In the
same loop, in the `feefilter` message processing, we call CTxMemPool::GetMinFee
(src/net_processing.cpp:4137), which locks m_pool.cs. Deadlock.
Anyway, that explains the change to locking behavior that I added to an
otherwise test-only PR.
To resolve the `ConstructTransaction` conflict I reverted to the existing code
then manually applied the diff (it adds a parameter then adds a giant pile of
code to the input loop).
This PR reduced the minrelayfee for Elements, but also brought in some
changes from upstream which I mostly just didn't take (since we've
already brought them in, in earlier parts of this rebase).
FIXME: we disable standardness checks for the non-PAK node in the PAK tests.
This is because of a bug in Elements which causes non-PAK nodes to reject
pegouts for standardness reasons. Need to fix it after the rebase.
Also uncommented a bunch of PSBT functional tests (had to add a fee output
to one transaction, update `find_output` to skip CT outputs, and change two
constant checks at the end of the commented-out section).
substitutes "for x in range(N):" by "for _ in range(N):"
indicates to the reader that a block is just repeated N times, and
that the loop counter is not used in the body
cc84460c16 test: move sync_blocks and sync_mempool functions to test_framework.py (Roy Shao)
Pull request description:
This PR moves `sync_blocks` and `sync_mempool` out from `test_framework/util.py` to `test_framework/test_framework.py` so they can take contextual information of test framework into account.
* Change all reference callers to call functions from `test_framework.py`
* Remove `**kwargs` which is not used
* Take into account of `timeout_factor` when respecting timeout in function implementations.
* Pass all tests by running `./test/functional/test_runner.py`
fixes#18930
ACKs for top commit:
MarcoFalke:
ACK cc84460c16 , reviewed with --color-moved=dimmed-zebra --color-moved-ws=ignore-all-space 💫
Tree-SHA512: a79b2a3fa842fc26a7aacb834bb2aea88b3049916c0b754e60002a77ce94bb5954e0ea3b436bf268e9295efb62d721dfef263a09339a55c684ac3fda388c275e
34e641a564 test: Remove unnecessary disconnect_nodes call in rpc_psbt.py (Danny Lee)
e6e7abd51a test: remove redundant two-way disconnect_nodes calls (Danny Lee)
a9bd1f9adf test: warn if nodes not connected before disconnect_nodes (Danny Lee)
Pull request description:
There's no harm in calling `disconnect_nodes` for nodes that weren't connected (in this case it's a no-op). However, detecting this case and logging a warning can help ensure that tests are behaving as expected.
In addition, since `disconnect_nodes` works bidirectionally, I removed all instances of this pattern:
```
disconnect_nodes(self.nodes[0], 1)
disconnect_nodes(self.nodes[1], 0)
```
ACKs for top commit:
MarcoFalke:
review ACK 34e641a564👔
amitiuttarwar:
ACK 34e641a564. Thanks for this test improvement!
Tree-SHA512: 344855ceb46c012d43c13d7c09f44d32dcb7645706d10ae1e4645d9edca54c6c6c13fee26b79480755cdfcdf39b4b5770b36bb03ce71ba002d5be8a27fe008af
Modifies the existing --factor flag to --timeout-factor to better express intent.
Adds rules to disable timeout if --timeout-factor is set to 0.
Modfies --timeout-factor help doc to inform users about this feature.
2742c34286 test: add factor option to adjust test timeouts (Harris)
Pull request description:
This PR adds a new option **factor** that can be used to adjust timeouts in various functional tests.
Several timeouts and functions from `authproxy`, `mininode`, `test_node` and `util` have been adapted to use this option. The factor-option definition is located in `test_framework.py`.
Fixes https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/18266
Also Fixes https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/18834
ACKs for top commit:
MarcoFalke:
Thanks! ACK 2742c34286
Tree-SHA512: 6d8421933ba2ac1b7db00b70cf2bc242d9842c48121c11aadc30b0985c4a174c86a127d6402d0cd73b993559d60d4f747872d21f9510cf4806e008349780d3ef
