There are a few layers of bullshit to this PR.
First, there is the fact that it adds a functional test gated on a new
config flag which is disabled by default, so it actually adds broken
code with no tests, waiting to ruin your day 520 PRs later when #21935
enables the broken test.
Second, the test appears to be superficially nonsensical because it
generates two transactions from different wallets and tries to compare
them for byte-for-byte equality, which doesn't make sense (at least)
because change outputs are randomly located...so something fishy is
going on.
Of course, in Elements the transactions are *not* equal half the time
because the outputs are permuted, which may have let me quickly figure
out the issue, except...
Third, there is a red herring of a bug where the two transactions have
slightly different feerates. This turns out to be caused by
CWallet::CalculateMaximumSignedTxSize using differently sized dummy
transactions depending on whether watchonly outputs are included (this
fact is conveniently disguised by #17211 slightly changing this logic;
this is an unmerged PR in Core that Elements has a backport of an old
version of). And the two wallets have different watchonly settings.
A sub-red-herring is the fact that this bug results in a discrepancy
of 0.25 vbytes, so it does not appear in Core but does appear in
Elements (there is a 3/16 probability that we should be so unlucky...
we are).
But this is all irrelevant, because...
Fourth, this test is actually super bullshit. The way it works is by
constructing a PSBT legitimately, saving this to disk, then re-"signs"
using the external signer interface by using a mock signer that
COMPLETELY REPLACES THE TRANSACTION UNDER CONSTRUCTION. So it doesn't
matter what the fee output looks like and it doesn't matter what the
order of the outputs. Core does not detect this malfeasance and
neither does Elements. For some reason, Core has a functional test
that explicitly checks that you can do this even though it is insane
and it is hard to think of non-malicious reasons to do it.
Fifth, while Elements fails to detect that its external signer is
actually changing the transaction out from under it, it DOES assume
that this won't happen. In CWallet::SignPSBT it blithely un-replaces
the transaction, which undermines the functional test.
Sixth, the original PR where this test was introduced has comments
locked, so anyone who spent six hours reverse-engineering this idiotic
broken test, and is still feeling charitable enough to discuss it with
the Core developors, can go pound sand.
Anyway, just disabled the broken test and move on with our lives.
This PR eliminates "strange regtest=0 behavior" in a test which had forced
us to disable the test for Elements. Can re-enable now :)
I also removed the `chain_in_args` parameter to `TestNode`, which Steven added
in https://github.com/ElementsProject/elements/pull/533 (which itself replaces
unconditionally adding chain={} on the command-line, which was added in #458).
These were added in the 0.17 rebase to deal with the job of starting bitcoind,
which then did not support the `chain=` command-line arg as well as elementsd,
which back then required this command-line arg.
This was causing some issues with the "check -acceptnonstdtxn doesn't work on
mainnet" test because it would add -chain=elementsregtest to the command-line
of a daemon that was supposed to be connecting to mainnet/liquidv1. It is
possible to override this behavior, but since 0.20+ versions of elementsd and
bitcoind have essentially the same support for chain= options, it seemed
cleaner to just eliminate the diff.
This uses a regtest-only RPC which checks that the chain is literally
"regtest". Since regtest is disabled in Elements (we use elementsregtest)
I weakened the check for this to just check that the chain name has
"regtest" somewhere in it. Hopefully this isn't too magical.
Everyone is _not_ connected in this test, so on slow machines
where this check triggers (e.g. the CI boxes) the test incorrectly
fails. This was also a source of (very infrequent) spurious failures
during the rebase.
Several conflicts in the C++ code related to the new `flags` parameter
to `CheckSignature` and the corresponding function being renamed upstream
to `CheckSignatureECDSA`.
Several conflicts in the test harness as Steven sorta pulled the new
upstream ECKey module into the Python code, and the actual upstream
code was slightly different. Also needed to update the feature_taproot
code to always use the non-RANGEPROOF sighash since dynafed is not
enabled in the Taproot test.
Also had to pull the `set_wif` method out of `ECKey` and inline it because
otherwise it triggers a "circular inclusion" error between script.py (which
would pull in `base58_to_bytes` from address.py) and address.py (which now
pulls in some taproot EC related stuff from script.py).
Noticed that #960 does not test the "sighash rangeproof flag set but no
witnesses" case.
fa730e9157 test: Avoid connecting to real network when running tests (MarcoFalke)
fa1b713941 test: Assume node is running in subtests (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
Introduced in #19884
ACKs for top commit:
Sjors:
ACK fa730e9157
Tree-SHA512: fe132a9ffe2fae1ab16857a3dec9839526fdf74d27a1ae794fbffca8356f639c4b916dc888b260281e9cc793916706c18d1687ebb5a076d4e1c481d218d308d3
faa137eb9e test: Speed up rpc_blockchain.py by removing miniwallet.generate() (MarcoFalke)
fa1fe80c75 test: Change address type from P2PKH to P2WSH in rpc_blockchain (MarcoFalke)
fa4d8f3169 test: Cache 25 mature coins for ADDRESS_BCRT1_P2WSH_OP_TRUE (MarcoFalke)
fad25153f5 test: Remove unused bug workaround (MarcoFalke)
faabce7d07 test: Start only the number of nodes that are needed (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
Speed up various tests:
* Remove unused nodes, which only consume time on start/stop
* Remove unused "bug workarounds"
* Remove the need for `miniwallet.generate()` by adding `miniwallet.scan_blocks()`. (On my system, with valgrind, generating 105 blocks takes 3.31 seconds. Rescanning 5 blocks takes 0.11 seconds.)
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
Code review ACK faa137eb9e
Tree-SHA512: ead1988d5aaa748ef9f8520af1e0bf812cf1d72e281ad22fbd172b7306d850053040526f8adbcec0b9a971c697a0ee7ee8962684644d65b791663eedd505a025
Somehow the CECKey impl is really broken if you want to set
a raw private key. Core master already has a new impl so I just
took that one and replaces the usages. This will probably be equivalent
with what would be rebased in at a later stage.
b4511e2e2e log: Prefix log messages with function name if -logsourcelocations is set (practicalswift)
Pull request description:
Prefix log messages with function name if `-logfunctionnames` is set.
Yes, exactly like `-logthreadnames` but for function names instead of thread names :)
This is a small developer ergonomics improvement: I've found this to be a cheap/simple way to correlate log output and originating function.
For me it beats the ordinary cycle of 1.) try to figure out a regexp matching the static part of the dynamic log message, 2.) `git grep -E 'Using .* MiB out of .* requested for signature cache'`, 3.) `mcedit filename.cpp` (`openemacs filename.cpp` works too!) and 4.) search for log message and scroll up to find the function name :)
Without any logging parameters:
```
$ src/bitcoind -regtest
2020-08-25T03:29:04Z Using RdRand as an additional entropy source
2020-08-25T03:29:04Z Using 16 MiB out of 32/2 requested for signature cache, able to store 524288 elements
2020-08-25T03:29:04Z Using 16 MiB out of 32/2 requested for script execution cache, able to store 524288 elements
2020-08-25T03:29:04Z Loaded best chain: hashBestChain=0fff88f13cb7b2c71f2a335e3a4fc328bf5beb436012afca590b1a11466e22ff height=0 date=2011-02-02T23:16:42Z progress=1.000000
2020-08-25T03:29:04Z block tree size = 1
2020-08-25T03:29:04Z nBestHeight = 0
2020-08-25T03:29:04Z Imported mempool transactions from disk: 0 succeeded, 0 failed, 0 expired, 0 already there, 0 waiting for initial broadcast
2020-08-25T03:29:04Z 0 addresses found from DNS seeds
```
With `-logthreadnames` and `-logfunctionnames`:
```
$ src/bitcoind -regtest -logthreadnames -logfunctionnames
2020-08-25T03:29:04Z [init] [ReportHardwareRand] Using RdRand as an additional entropy source
2020-08-25T03:29:04Z [init] [InitSignatureCache] Using 16 MiB out of 32/2 requested for signature cache, able to store 524288 elements
2020-08-25T03:29:04Z [init] [InitScriptExecutionCache] Using 16 MiB out of 32/2 requested for script execution cache, able to store 524288 elements
2020-08-25T03:29:04Z [init] [LoadChainTip] Loaded best chain: hashBestChain=0fff88f13cb7b2c71f2a335e3a4fc328bf5beb436012afca590b1a11466e22ff height=0 date=2011-02-02T23:16:42Z progress=1.000000
2020-08-25T03:29:04Z [init] [AppInitMain] block tree size = 1
2020-08-25T03:29:04Z [init] [AppInitMain] nBestHeight = 0
2020-08-25T03:29:04Z [loadblk] [LoadMempool] Imported mempool transactions from disk: 0 succeeded, 0 failed, 0 expired, 0 already there, 0 waiting for initial broadcast
2020-08-25T03:29:04Z [dnsseed] [ThreadDNSAddressSeed] 0 addresses found from DNS seeds
```
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
Code review ACK b4511e2e2e
MarcoFalke:
review ACK b4511e2e2e🌃
Tree-SHA512: d100f5364630c323f31d275259864c597f7725e462d5f4bdedcc7033ea616d7fc0d16ef1b2af557e692f4deea73c6773ccfc681589e7bf6ba970b9ec169040c7
Add a check that new connections from the test framework to the
node have the correct user agent string. This makes bugs easier
to detect if the user agent string ever changes.
The messages.py module should contain code and helpers for
[de]serializing p2p messages. Specific usage of those messages should
be in p2p.py. Therefore specify the nServices value in the calling code,
not in the messages.py module.
messages.py is for message and primitive data structures. Specifics
about the test framework's p2p implementation should be in p2p.py.
Also rename to P2P_VERSION_RELAY. Also rename msg_version.nRelay to
relay. In Bitcoin Core, this is referred to as fRelay, since it's a
bool, so this field has always been misnamed.
The messages.py module should contain code and helpers for
[de]serializing p2p messages. Specific usage of those messages should
be in p2p.py. Therefore move MY_SUBVERSION to p2p.py.
Also rename to P2P_SUBVERSION.
The messages.py module should contain code and helpers for
[de]serializing p2p messages. Specific usage of those messages should
be in p2p.py. Therefore move MY_VERSION to p2p.py.
Also rename to P2P_VERSION to distinguish it from
other versioning used in Bitcoin/Bitcoin Core.
Also always set the nVersion field in CBlockLocator to 0 and ignore the
field in deserialized messages. The field is not currently used for
anything in Bitcoin Core.
The messages.py module should contain code and helpers for
[de]serializing p2p messages. Specific usage of those messages should
be in p2p.py. Therefore move MIN_VERSION_SUPPORTED to p2p.py.
Also rename to MIN_P2P_VERSION_SUPPORTED to distinguish it from
other versioning used in Bitcoin/Bitcoin Core.
de85af5cce test: store subversion (user agent) as string in msg_version (Sebastian Falbesoner)
Pull request description:
It seems more natural to treat the "subversion" field (=user agent string, see [BIP 14](https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0014.mediawiki#Proposal)) of a node as pure string rather than a bytestring within the test framework. This is also suggested with the naming prefix in `msg_version.strSubVer`: one probably wouldn't expect a field starting with "str" to be a bytestring that needs further decoding to be useful. This PR moves the encoding/decoding parts to the serialization/deserialization routines so that the user doesn't have to bother with that anymore.
Note that currently, in the master branch the `msg_version.strSubVer` is never read (only in `msg_version.__repr__`); However, one issue that is solved by this PR came up while testing #19509 (not merged yet): A decoding script for binary message capture files takes use of the functional test framework convert it into JSON format. Bytestrings will be convered to hexstrings, while pure strings will (surprise surprise) end up without modification in the file.
So without this patch, we get:
```
$ jq . out.json | grep -m5 strSubVer
"strSubVer": "2f5361746f7368693a32312e39392e302f"
"strSubVer": "2f5361746f7368693a302e32302e312f"
"strSubVer": "2f5361746f7368693a32312e39392e302f"
"strSubVer": "2f5361746f7368693a302e32302e312f"
"strSubVer": "2f5361746f7368693a32312e39392e302f"
```
After this patch:
```
$ jq . out2.json | grep -m5 strSubVer
"strSubVer": "/Satoshi:21.99.0/"
"strSubVer": "/Satoshi:0.20.1/"
"strSubVer": "/Satoshi:21.99.0/"
"strSubVer": "/Satoshi:0.20.1/"
"strSubVer": "/Satoshi:21.99.0/"
```
ACKs for top commit:
jnewbery:
utACK de85af5cce
Tree-SHA512: ff23642705c858e8387a625537dfec82e6b8a15da6d99b8d12152560e52d243ba17431b602b26f60996d897e00e3f37dcf8dc8a303ffb1d544df29a5937080f9
